Dior, Prada and AI: why artists are returning to Christmas advertising

7 My reading
Illustrated mice gathered around a white Prada bag, with cheese and a leopard-print shoe.

Hello everyone!

Well, with the change of time, I think we’re all a bit disoriented. It’s night time much too early and we quickly feel like making some hot chocolate in front of a good Christmas movie or a Disney movie.

Personally, on Halloween, I always like to watch Hocus Pocus, I can't tell you why, but it's kind of a ritual, like sometimes Vampire Diaries, Twilight ect... Then, as soon as winter arrives, I return to Les 101 Dalmatiens, Les Aristochats or Ratatouille (Yes, yes 😂). I already know the stories by heart, but that absolutely doesn’t stop me from rereading them, and I’d rather not know how many times I’ve seen them. Les 101 Dalmatiens in my life.

It’s probably for this reason that the Christmas campaigns by Dior and Prada have captured my attention. And apparently, I’m not the only one: that’s actually the whole point of a successful campaign. They stand out because they go against the images generated by AI that we see everywhere. I discovered them on Instagram, before stumbling upon several articles, notably the one on the @lefiltre account, and then I started looking for the artists who had worked on them.

Of course, I wanted to know who was behind these campaigns. Just show me some nice designs and I’m off on my quest...

But for once, I didn’t stay just because the images were beautiful or because it was Dior and Prada. I especially loved feeling that there were people behind it.

Christmas campaigns that I wanted to watch to the end

For Drawing Prada, Maya Hawke's photographs are mixed with hand-drawn animations directed by John Pomeroy. You can see the features, the movements, and the small imperfections. There is, in particular, this big fox that immediately made me think of the characters from old cartoons.

It’s very Prada, of course, but a little less "cold" than some fashion campaigns. The design brings something sweet and almost familiar. I wanted to stop and look at the images, to see the details and understand how they were made. It seems silly, but it’s been a long time since a Christmas advertisement made me feel this way; usually, I just look at the decorations and wonder where they got their garlands from.

At Dior, it is Sylvain Chomet, the director of Les Triplettes de Belleville, who conceived the Christmas film. Again, you immediately recognize an entire universe. The characters have real personality and the film tells something, even in just a few minutes. I believe that’s exactly what I expect from a good campaign: that it takes me into its world and that I leave with something from it.

What bothers me about some AI-generated images

I am not at all against artificial intelligence and I am not going to pretend I never use it. It is very practical and some images are stunning. Sometimes even too much and it becomes difficult to know what is real, what has been edited and what never existed.

In a Christmas advertisement, this doubt is absolutely not dramatic. When it comes to news or politics, it’s obviously more complicated. It’s especially at that moment that I find the thing worrying, because an image can circulate very quickly even before someone takes the time to check where the source comes from. It’s a bit like the rumors at school, you see the kind of thing.

As for advertising, my problem is simpler: a lot of images generated by AI do nothing for me. They are perfect, everything is in the right place and yet I move on to the next one without even thinking about it. There is a lack of intention, awkwardness, an idea, or simply a person whose gaze I recognize.

It is also for this reason that I had wanted to talk about Sète’s decision to stop promoting posters created entirely with AI. The question isn’t to reject everything. It’s more about asking what the tool actually brings and what we lose when we entrust the entire creation to it.

No, I am not afraid for my profession

Sometimes I am asked if all this worries me for my work as a graphic designer and web designer. Honestly, no. I still sleep very well at night! I even think that AI is already doing some of the work.

I was confronted with the same thing in the tattoo.

People who are looking for a quick and inexpensive image will use these tools, whatever one may think of them. Those who want an universe, a sensibility and someone to exchange with will continue to turn to creatives whose work they love. You don’t just choose a graphic designer because he knows how to use a software program. You choose him or her for their colors, their references, their ideas and their way of looking at things.

At least that’s what I’m trying to build with Minuit d’Orsay. My projects are inevitably fueled by the places I photograph, the books I keep, the campaigns I love, the films I’ve seen, and even the cartoons I watched as a child. It’s precisely this part that cannot be generated by writing three lines in a file about Chat GPT or Claude.

The wheel may be turning a bit in the artists' favor

After hearing for months that AI would replace graphic designers, photographers, illustrators and pretty much every creative profession, I found it quite gratifying to see Dior and Prada put artists at the center of their campaigns.

I don’t think this is the end of generative imagery, far from it. But maybe brands are also starting to see their limits. With the ability to produce everything so quickly and neatly, you end up wanting to find a certain touch, a personality, and something a little less perfect.

Ultimately, I believe that AI is like many things: very good, but well-balanced. When it accompanies an idea, it can be brilliant. When it becomes the entire idea, I get bored pretty quickly.

I devoted a more professional article to the production of the campaigns for Dior, Prada and Coca-Cola on The Minuit d’Orsay website. Here, I wanted to tell you why these drawings had touched me and why they made me want to revisit them. Les 101 Dalmatiens. Still. Fortunately, I don’t need an excuse to make another Disney movie!

And what cartoon do you still watch when you feel like something comforting? And do you find the ads created by AI as appealing as those created by artists? I would be delighted to read your comments in the comments section.

PAR
Tamara
Chaudesaigues

Welcome! My name is Tamara, web designer and founder of Minuit d’Orsay in Paris. On this blog, I share my looks, the beauty products I use, my discoveries, and the places I visit. There are also my photographs, the exhibitions I visit, my travels — often to London — and the projects that occupy my days. Design and tattooing are part of my journey and what I tell here. You will find my opinions, my tests, and the details I want to keep and share with you.

0 comments

Be the first to leave a comment.

Add a comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like

Contact me

Name
Preferred city